Washington approves the investment map while the grid goes dark
The Treasury granted all 18 Opportunity Zones the territory asked for. The same week, its power authority warned of worse outages and the Census Bureau projected a 41% population fall by 2100.
CHARLOTTE AMALIE. In the space of a single week, the United States Virgin Islands received a federal vote of confidence in its investment future and a fresh reminder that its present barely keeps the lights on. The distance between those two facts is the territory's central problem, and this month it was on full display.
On November 12, the United States Treasury approved all 18 of the census tracts the territory had nominated for the next round of federal Opportunity Zones, according to the VI Consortium. The designation, which takes effect in 2027, lets investors defer and reduce taxes on capital gains they plow into the approved areas, and for a small economy hungry for outside capital it is a genuine tool. Every tract the territory asked for was granted, which is as strong a signal as Washington's tax code offers that the Virgin Islands are open for the kind of development the incentive is designed to pull in.
The grid that cannot keep up
The trouble is what that capital would be plugging into. Four days earlier, on November 8, the Virgin Islands Water and Power Authority warned of worsening outages on St. Thomas and St. John, the same chronic unreliability that has defined life and business in the territory for years. The politics around it turned sharp.
Governor-elect Stacey Plaskett accused the utility of failing to pursue an emergency offer of help from the United States Department of Energy. The outgoing governor, Albert Bryan, countered on November 10 that a formal WAPA emergency declaration "would accomplish little." The exchange, between the administration on its way out and the one about to take office, is the sound of a transition inheriting a problem neither side has solved.
An Opportunity Zone is a promise to investors that a place has a future worth betting on. A power grid that cannot guarantee electricity to St. Thomas is a daily argument to the contrary. The territory is, in effect, marketing its upside to Wall Street while its own residents run generators, and no tax incentive closes that gap. Capital can be coaxed with deferral and exemption, but it also reads the operating conditions, and reliable power is the first line on that page.
The territory is selling its future to investors while struggling to power its present for residents.
The number under everything
Beneath the week's news sat a figure that reframes all of it. On November 6 the VI Consortium reported United States Census Bureau projections showing the territory's population falling 41% over this century, from 83,896 in 2026 to 49,331 by 2100. A projection is not a prophecy, and three-quarters of a century is long enough for much to change.
But a territory already struggling to keep its grid running and its streets safe, with a homicide count that reached 48 for the year after a fatal shooting on St. Croix on November 12, cannot treat a steady loss of people as someone else's problem. Population is the base on which an economy, a tax roll and a labor market all sit, and the projected direction is down.
The case the Virgin Islands has to make
Put the week together and the territory's task is clear, if not easy. The Opportunity Zone approval gives it a credible pitch to investors for the first time in a while. Whether that pitch converts depends on the unglamorous work the headlines rarely celebrate, fixing the power supply, bringing down the violence, and giving residents a reason to stay rather than join the outflow the Census Bureau has sketched.
Incentives bring capital to places that already work. They do not, on their own, make a place work.
The Virgin Islands have the rarer thing, a moment when Washington has said yes. The question the incoming Plaskett administration inherits is whether the territory can meet that yes with a grid that holds, a crime rate that falls, and a population it can persuade to stay. The investors reading the Opportunity Zone map this month will be reading the outage notices too.
Both are public. Both are the Virgin Islands.
Read more at The Caribbean Ledger ›