TCLThe Caribbean LedgerEvery island · One Caribbean
‹ Back
Sports | West Indies

West Indies win the series in Bangladesh, and get a warning in St Kitts

Jomel Warrican's 16 wickets carry the senior side to a 1-0 Test win abroad. The same week, a West Indies A team is swept at home by the England Lions. Both are the real picture.

West Indies win the series in Bangladesh, and get a warning in St Kitts

SYLHET. West Indies won a Test series on the other side of the world this month, which is the kind of sentence that has been rare enough lately to be worth stopping on. The senior side took its two-match series in Bangladesh one to nil, sealing it with a draw in the second Test at Sylhet that ended on November 9. It was built in the first Test at Mirpur, which West Indies won by eight wickets, and it was won, as the captain was first to say, by one man with a ball in his hand.

Jomel Warrican, the left-arm spinner, took 16 wickets across the two matches, nine in Mirpur, where he was named player of the match, and seven in Sylhet. He was player of the series, and his captain, Roston Chase, did not hedge about it. "He really kept us in this series and really won the series for us," Chase said, as reported by the Jamaica Gleaner on November 10.

Shamar Joseph bowling for West Indies
Shamar Joseph of West Indies in the second Test against Bangladesh. Photo: The Ledger Desk

Chase called the Sylhet pitch "a bit slower than the first one" and acknowledged that bad light had helped push the second Test to a draw. "We wanted to win both games, but it didn't happen," he said. The result lifted West Indies to sixth in the International Cricket Council's Test rankings.

A win worth keeping in proportion

It is worth being clear-eyed about what this is and is not. A series win in Bangladesh is not a return to the heights of the 1980s, and Bangladesh at home remains a side West Indies should be competitive against. But West Indies cricket has absorbed so many bruising results in the long format that a clean away series victory, with a spinner carrying the attack on subcontinental surfaces, is a real and welcome data point rather than a sentimental one. Winning in conditions that do not suit you, which spin on the subcontinent historically has not for Caribbean seamers, is the harder trick, and this side managed it.

Kavem Hodge of West Indies on the field
Kavem Hodge of West Indies during the series. Photo: The Ledger Desk
1-0West Indies' Test series win in Bangladesh
16Warrican's series wickets, player of the series
6thWest Indies' new ICC Test ranking
0-3West Indies A, swept at home by England Lions

The warning sitting one island group away

And yet the week carried a second result that complicates the first, and it happened on home soil in St Kitts. While the senior team was winning in Sylhet, a West Indies A side was being comprehensively beaten by the England Lions, England's second string, in a series of unofficial one-day internationals at Warner Park and the Conaree Sports Club. The Lions won the first by four wickets, the second by 276 runs, a margin that is less a scoreline than a verdict, and the third by six wickets, with a fourth to follow on November 14.

In the second match the Lions opener Ben McKinney hit what Wisden recorded as the fastest century in Lions one-day history. The schedule is set out on the fixtures pages of Khel Now and CricTracker.

An England Lions batter in action
An England Lions batter in action. Photo: The Ledger Desk
The first team is winning in Asia while the second team is being routed at home. Both results are the real West Indies.

Put the two side by side and you have the honest state of the regional game. The first eleven, built around experienced professionals like Chase and Warrican, can still win a Test series in difficult conditions. The layer beneath it, the A team that is supposed to be the production line for the next decade, was outclassed at home by another nation's reserves, and by an enormous margin in one match. A cricketing culture is only as strong as its second string, because the second string is what the first becomes when the current generation retires.

Warrican is 33. Chase is in his thirties. The men who lost by 276 runs in St Kitts are, in theory, the inheritance.

What the board should take from the fortnight

None of this is an argument for gloom, and it would be a disservice to Warrican's fortnight to use his achievement as a stick. It is an argument for attention. Cricket West Indies has spent years reorganizing its domestic structure, and the senior result suggests the top of the system can still produce.

The St Kitts result suggests the middle of it cannot yet produce enough. The two are not in tension. They are the same message at two altitudes, that the Caribbean can still find eleven cricketers good enough to win abroad, and has not yet rebuilt the depth that keeps a team winning once those eleven are gone.

For now, the region can enjoy the thing in front of it. A West Indies Test series win, earned away, with a Caribbean spinner as its architect, is a good Caribbean sports story in a year that has not had a surplus of them. The work it points to, down in the development sides where England's reserves just handed out a lesson, is the longer assignment.

An England batter in action
An England batter in action. Photo: The Ledger Desk

Both were on the scoreboard this week. A serious cricketing public reads both.

Read more at The Caribbean Ledger ›