On an ordinary Tuesday, Puerto Rico's grid warned it might go dark again
With four generating units down or capped, LUMA warned that 100,000 customers faced load shedding on October 27. No storm was involved, which is precisely the point.

SAN JUAN. Puerto Rico's electricity system spent the last week of October doing what it has done too often this year: warning that it might not keep the lights on. On the evening of Tuesday, October 27, LUMA Energy, the private operator that runs the island's transmission and distribution network, warned of a high risk of load shedding during peak evening demand, estimating that about 100,000 customers could be affected, according to the San Juan daily Metro Puerto Rico. The cause was not a storm.
It was a shortage of generation, several plants down or running below capacity at the same time.
The list of ailing units was long. Metro Puerto Rico reported that Palo Seco Units 3 and 4 had cut output around 4:10 p.m. after a disturbance still under investigation, that Costa Sur Unit 5 was out of service for repairs to a transformer, that San Juan Unit 5 had gone offline at midday, and that Aguirre Unit 2 was limited to 90 megawatts by an operational cap. LUMA said it was coordinating with the generating companies to add power and reduce the impact on customers, but could not guarantee that load shedding would be avoided. Genera PR, the company that operates the island's generation fleet, issued its own warning that available supply might fall short of projected demand.
The episode is part of a pattern that has made the island's power providers politically radioactive. Puerto Rico has suffered repeated large-scale outages, and residents and officials have increasingly demanded that LUMA and Genera PR be removed, a grievance this newspaper examined when it named Puerto Rico its Island in Focus in early October. The split structure of the system, with LUMA moving electricity and Genera PR making it, has become a point of friction in itself, each able to point to the other when supply falls short, as both effectively did on October 27.
The economic cost of an unreliable grid is not confined to the evenings it fails. Businesses that cannot count on power build the expense of generators and lost production into their plans, investors weigh it when deciding whether to commit capital, and residents who can afford solar-and-battery systems effectively opt out of the public grid, leaving the households that cannot to bear the brunt of the shortfalls. A load-shedding warning that reaches 100,000 customers is a headline for a night. The chronic uncertainty behind it is a drag on the island's economy every day, and it is the backdrop against which the calls to remove LUMA and Genera PR have grown louder.
Behind the finger-pointing is an unresolved structural problem. Puerto Rico is still rebuilding a grid that Hurricane Maria destroyed in 2017, on an island where 3.2 million people live and a large share cannot afford the private generators and solar systems that insulate wealthier households from the failures. Load-shedding warnings that arrive on an ordinary Tuesday, with no hurricane in sight, are the clearest evidence that the rebuilding has not kept pace with the demands placed on it. Until generation capacity is restored and modernized, the island will keep living one hot evening away from the next warning, and the political pressure on its power companies will keep rising.
Read more at The Caribbean Ledger ›